Camaena saturnia ( Gould, 1846 )

Sutcharit, Chirasak & Panha, Somsak, 2021, Overlooked for a century: Taxonomic status of Camaena saturnia (Gould, 1846) (Eupulmonata: Camaenidae), Raffles Bulletin of Zoology 69, pp. 253-261 : 254-258

publication ID

https://doi.org/ 10.26107/RBZ-2021-0020

publication LSID

lsid:zoobank.org:pub:CD14011D-FB89-487A-A8FC-363605AD0DF6

persistent identifier

https://treatment.plazi.org/id/A06187B0-8219-3009-5FFC-F906FB3CBC81

treatment provided by

Diego

scientific name

Camaena saturnia ( Gould, 1846 )
status

 

Camaena saturnia ( Gould, 1846) View in CoL

( Figs. 1–3 View Fig View Fig View Fig )

Helix saturnia Gould, 1846: 98 , 99, type locality: Tavoy [Dawei, Tanintharyi Region, Myanmar]; 1862: 198; Pfeiffer, 1853: 250; 1859: 199, 300; Hanley & Theobald, 1870: 13, pl. 25 fig. 3; Johnson, 1964: 145.

Helix (Phania) saturnia – Martens in Albers, 1860: 157.

Helix (Camaena) saturnia – Pilsbry, 1891: 203, 204, pl. 60 fig. 5.

Camaena saturnia View in CoL – Pilsbry, 1894: 104, pl. 60 fig. 5; Gude, 1914: 151, 152; Richardson, 1985: 77, 78.

Hemiplecta View in CoL ? saturnia View in CoL – Godwin-Austen, 1898: 73.

Camaena ngocthachi Huber in Thach, 2020: 86, figs. 932–934, type locality: suburb of Phang Nga city, Phang Nga Province, South Thailand. New synonym.

Material examined. Possible syntype NHMUK 20210010 About NHMUK ex. Cuming collection (1 shell; Fig. 2A View Fig ) from Tavoy. NHMUK 1888.12 About NHMUK .4.2004 ex. Theobald collection (1 shell; Fig. 2B View Fig ) from Tenasserim. Holotype of C. ngocthachi , MNHN-IM-2000-35587 ( Fig. 2C View Fig ) from Suburb of Phang Nga City , Phang Nga Province, Thailand. Limestone outcrop at Phra (Buddha) Cave , Lenya National Park , Tanintharyi Township, Tanintharyi Region, Myanmar (11°13′46″N, 99°10′34″E): CUMZ 7434 View Materials (1 broken shell). Klong Laan , Suratthani Province , Thailand: CUMZ 2562 View Materials (1 shell; height 31.8 mm, width 53.5 mm). Pala-u waterfall, Phetchaburi Province, Thailand: CUMZ 2561 View Materials (2 intact + 1 broken shells; height 29.4 mm, width 52.0 mm, height 26.9 mm, width 51.4 mm), CUMZ 4152 View Materials (1 broken shell). Samet Chun Waterfall , Khanom District, Nakhon Sri Thammarat Province, Thailand (9°08′09.2″N, 99°50′53.2″E): CUMZ 7433 View Materials (1 ethanol preserved + 1 juvenile shell, height 25.3 mm, width 47.7 mm; Figs. 2D View Fig , 3A, B, D, E View Fig ). GoogleMaps

Shell. Shell dextral, relatively thin, and thick-lens-shaped ( Fig. 2 View Fig ). Apex obtuse; embryonic shell rather large, about 2½ whorls, sculptured with regular parallel growth lines; following whorls nearly smooth-surfaced with fine and regular growth lines, and tiny nodules spread on last whorl. Shell reddish-brown to dark brown in colour; periostracum thin and transparent. Whorls 5 to 6 increasing regularly. Spire dome-shaped to little elevated; suture very wide and shallow to little impressed. Last whorl large and angular with strong peripheral keel. Aperture wide, rhomboid-shaped, whitish inside, and connected by thin whitish to transparent parietal callus. Peristome white to brownish, little thickened, and widely expanded. Columella dilated, whitish, and slightly curved. Umbilicus perforated and widely opened.

Genitalia. Atrium (at) short. Penis (p) somewhat slender and long. Epiphallus (e) relatively short and folded. Penial retractor muscle (pr) long and attached near penis. Flagellum (fl) very long, nearly equivalent to length of penis and epiphallus, and coiled terminally. Vas deferens (vd) narrow tube passing forward from free oviduct and joining at junction of epiphallus and flagellum ( Fig. 3A View Fig ). Internal wall of penis corrugated and exhibiting series of thin longitudinal penial pilasters (pp), which form fringe around penial verge. Penial verge (pv) long-conical-shaped, and with nearly smooth surface ( Fig. 3B View Fig ).

Vagina (v) cylindrical, shorter than penis, and held in position by a series of muscle filaments arising from foot floor ( Fig. 3A View Fig ). Gametolytic duct (gd) very long, similar diameter as vagina, then tapering to a narrow and long tube, and connected to swollen and elliptical gametolytic sac (gs). Free oviduct (fo) very short. Oviduct (ov) not enlarged. Albumen gland (ag) slightly enlarged and tongue shaped. Hermaphroditic duct (hd) twisted, curved, and connected to alveoli hermaphroditic gland (hg). Internally, vagina possesses irregular longitudinal vaginal pilasters (vp) that exhibit a series of swollen and smooth ridges. Vaginal pilasters are apparently uniform throughout entire vaginal chamber ( Fig. 3B View Fig ).

Radula. Radula arranged in a nearly straight row with about 137 teeth with the formula 68-(21-22)-1-(21-22)-68. Central tooth unicuspid with obtuse cusp ( Fig. 3D View Fig ). Lateral teeth unicuspid, oblique-shaped, and with obtuse cusp ( Fig. 3D, E View Fig ). Marginal teeth starting around teeth no. 21 to 22. Inner marginal teeth bicuspid; ectocone large with dull cusp; endocone very small, located near the tip and with pointed cusp ( Fig. 3E View Fig ). Outer marginal teeth small and tricuspid; endocone and mesocone with rather large and pointed cusps; ectocone very small and located at base of the teeth ( Fig. 3E View Fig ).

Distribution. The historical record of this species is known only from the type locality “Tavoy” and the broad geographical area of “Tenasserim” ( Hanley & Theobald, 1870; Pilsbry, 1891; Gude, 1914). Both records are currently located in the Tanintharyi Region, southern Myanmar

( Fig. 1 View Fig ). A recent study collected records from several localities along the east coast of the Tenasserim Range in Petchaburi , Suratthani, Phang Nga and Nakhon Sri Thammarat Provinces, Thailand. The southern limit of the distribution of the species is possibly in Phang Nga Province .

Remarks. Although C. saturnia has a wide distribution, ranging from Myanmar to Thailand, its populations are low in density and quite rare. In this study, only four heavily worn shells and one live specimen were collected from the non-limestone areas examined. The live snail was found among leaf litter with decaying leaves and rotten logs in primary forest. Gradually increasing deforestation is probably the main reason for the restricted habitats and population decline of this species.

The nominal species Camaena ngocthachi was recently described from southern Thailand based on one holotype now deposited in the MNHN collection and two paratypes housed in the author’s personal collection. The holotype MNHN-IM-2000-35587 ( Fig. 2C View Fig ) is a worn specimen showing no informative character differences from the syntype of C. saturnia ( Fig. 2A View Fig ) and other specimens from nearby areas ( Fig. 2B, D View Fig ). Therefore, we do not hesitate to synonymise Camaena ngocthachi as a junior subjective synonym of C. saturnia .

Pilsbry (1891) stated that C. saturnia has a similar shell to C. ochthoplax ( Benson, 1860) . For comparison, C. saturnia has a smaller shell size (width about 51 mm) with a strong peripheral keel on the last whorl, widely opened umbilicus, nearly smooth shell surface, and a very shallow suture. In contrast, C. ochthoplax ( Fig. 4A View Fig ) has a larger shell (width about 68 mm), a rounded last whorl, rimate umbilicus, shell surface with strong growth lines and rough with malleations, and impressed suture. Gude (1914) also noted that C. saturnia is similar to C. vanbuensis Smith, 1896 . However, the recently examined type specimen clearly shows no similarity between them. Camaena saturnia has a thinner and smaller shell, a widely opened umbilicus, and nearly smooth or thin growth lines of the shell surface. On the other hand, C. vanbuensis ( Fig. 4C View Fig ) has a relatively larger and thicker shell, nearly closed umbilicus, and shell surface with strong malleated surface.

The other two umbilicate species, C. pachychila ( Smith, 1893) and C. suprafusca Möllendorff, 1898 , also closely resemble C. saturnia . However, C. pachychila ( Fig. 4B View Fig ) from Vietnam is distinct in having narrow brownish spiral bands on the periphery and below the periphery surrounding the umbilicus and more convex whorls. In contrast, C. suprafusca ( Fig. 4D View Fig ) from Laos has a wide-angled peripheral keel, dome-shaped spire, last whorl inflated below the periphery, and reddishbrown spiral bands on the periphery and below the periphery surrounding the umbilicus (for further comparison, see Inkhavilay et al., 2019: fig. 47e). However, C. suprafusca has been treated as a junior synonym of C. pachychilus without clear evidence ( Páll-Gergely et al., 2020). The molecular phylogenies of the umbilicate group ( Wang et al., 2020) and sinistral group ( Ai et al., 2016; Ding et al., 2016) clearly indicate that the traditional morphological-based classification using shell and genitalia characters is effective and able to differentiate species. In addition, field observation and a genetic study both revealed that Camaena species tend to be locally endemic and are restricted to primary forest, which may play an important role in their isolation ( Ding et al., 2016; Wang et al., 2020). Therefore, the opinion of Páll-Gergely et al. (2020) is still provisional; we treat C. suprafusca as a distinct species and await further data from genitalia anatomy and molecular studies.

Kingdom

Animalia

Phylum

Mollusca

Class

Gastropoda

Order

Stylommatophora

Family

Camaenidae

Genus

Camaena

Loc

Camaena saturnia ( Gould, 1846 )

Sutcharit, Chirasak & Panha, Somsak 2021
2021
Loc

Camaena ngocthachi

Thach NN 2020: 86
2020
Loc

Hemiplecta

Godwin-Austen HH 1898: 73
1898
Loc

Camaena saturnia

Richardson L 1985: 77
Gude GK 1914: 151
Pilsbry HA 1894: 104
1894
Loc

Helix (Phania) saturnia

Albers JC 1860: 157
1860
Loc

Helix saturnia

Johnson RI 1964: 145
Hanley SCT & Theobald W 1870: 13
Pfeiffer L 1859: 199
Pfeiffer L 1853: 250
Gould AA 1846: 98
1846
Darwin Core Archive (for parent article) View in SIBiLS Plain XML RDF