Meridiania cf. M. convexa Case 1994

Ebersole, Jun A., Cicimurri, David J. & Stringer, Gary L., 2019, Taxonomy and biostratigraphy of the elasmobranchs and bony fishes (Chondrichthyes and Osteichthyes) of the lower-to-middle Eocene (Ypresian to Bartonian) Claiborne Group in Alabama, USA, including an analysis of otoliths, European Journal of Taxonomy 585, pp. 1-274 : 138-140

Meridiania cf. M. convexa Case 1994

Fig. 51

Meridiania convexa Case, 1994a: 124 , pl. 13 figs 282–291, pl. 14 figs 292–306.

Material examined

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA – Alabama • 4 isolated teeth; Claiborne Group ; MSC 38820, MSC 38822 (2 specimens), MSC 38877 .

Description

Two morphologies represented in our sample. One represented by a partial tooth that is wider than long; the preserved lateral margin is angular. Crown appears to have had a straight occlusal outline; the highly worn occlusal surface largely consists of dentine with thin outer enameloid layer. Labial crown foot rounded; lingual crown foot has shallow transverse furrow. Root polyaulocorhize; relatively few lamellae separated by wide nutritive grooves.

Second morphology includes teeth with a hexagonal crown. One such tooth worn flat through in vivo wear. Occlusal surface formed of dentine surrounded by a layer of enameloid. All have thin and rounded labial margin; transverse furrows are located at the lingual crown foot. All lateral teeth with one-to-two nutritive grooves. Basal attachment surfaces of lobes triangular. The two other teeth with transverse cusp at center of the crown; duller on one specimen due to ablation. Enameloid of ablated specimen is polished and lacks detail. Remaining tooth exhibits discontinuous vertical ridges on the labial and lingual sides of cusp.

Remarks

The discovery of Meridiania in the Tallahatta Formation and Gosport Sand was surprising, considering both occurrences would represent significant range extensions from Zone NP11 strata of the Ypresian Nanjemoy Formation of Virginia ( Kent 1999b). In fact, when MSC 38822.1 ( Fig. 51–L ) was first encountered within the ACl-15 Gosport Sand sample (Zone NP17), our immediate suspicion was that the specimen represented a contaminant. However, the discovery of an additional tooth from the same locality (MSC 38822.2, Fig. 51 E–H), as well as a tooth from the Gosport Sand at site ACl-4 (MSC 38820, Fig. 51 M–O), spurred us to reconsider this possibility. Closer inspection of these specimens revealed similar preservation to the other myliobatiform teeth within the Gosport samples from both localities.

Unfortunately, only one of the four teeth we examined is preserved well enough for meaningful comparison to M. convexa , the only species currently within the genus (i.e., Case 1994a; Kent 1999b; Cicimurri 2010). The three Gosport Sand Meridiania specimens we examined are morphologically similar to type specimens of M. convexa , which Case (1994a) interpreted as having been part of a dentition similar to that of Dasyatis . However, Cicimurri (2010) reevaluated the dentition of M. convexa and concluded that the type material represented lateral teeth in a dental battery that was more similar to that of Rhinoptera . The broken tooth recovered from the Tallahatta Formation is likely equivalent to the Meridiania tooth shown by Cicimurri (2010: 103, fig. 3.1), which was considered to represent a proximal lateral tooth.

The best specimen, MSC 38822.1 ( Fig. 51 A–D), was compared to a sample of several hundred M. convexa lateral teeth from the upper Thanetian Williamsburg Formation of South Carolina (at SC). The only notable differences between the samples is that MSC 38822.1 exhibits a slightly thicker crown margin and the furrows at the lingual crown foot are more concave. However, as Cicimurri (2010) noted, the crowns of M. convexa lateral teeth are variable and the slight differences observed on the Gosport Sand specimen cannot be accurately interpreted at this time. Suffice to say, the specimens represent a significant range extension for the genus, from Zone NP11 to Zone NP14 (Tallahatta Formation), with the youngest known record occurring in the Gosport Sand (Zone NP17).

Stratigraphic and geographic range in Alabama

The specimens in our sample were collected from the lower Tallahatta Formation at site ADl-1, the basal Gosport Sand at site ACl-4, and the Gosport Sand at site ACl-15. Upper Ypresian and middle Bartonian, zones NP14 and NP17.

Figures

Fig. 51. Meridiania cf. M. convexa Case 1994, teeth. A–D. MSC 38877, median tooth, lower Tallahatta Formation. A. Oral view. B. Labial view. C. Profile view. D. Basal view. E–H. MSC 38822.2, lateral tooth, Gosport Sand. E. Oral view. F. Labial view. G. Lingual view. H. Basal view. I–L. MSC 38822.1, lateral tooth, Gosport Sand. I. Oral view. J. Labial view. K. Lingual view. L. Basal view. M–O. MSC 38820, lateral tooth, basal Gosport Sand. M. Oral view. N. Lingual view. O. Basal view. Labial at top in oral and basal views. Scale bars = 2 mm.